Hey there X-Maniacs, I'll be posting 4(!!!)new reviews today! I figure the best way to shake my case of the vacation doldrums is to FORCE myself to do reviews, and LOTS of them! So tonight I'll be doing a review for all four parts of the War of the Supermen mini-series that just wrapped up. Did I enjoy the War of the Supermen? Did I hate it? Do you care?!? All answers will soon be revealed...
War of the Supermen #1: Writers: James Robinson & Sterling Gates. Pencils: Jamal Igle.
Review: With Brainiac's failed invasion of New Krypton, and Lex Luthor's role as Brainiac's advisor discovered by the Kryptonians, General Zod has declared war on the planet Earth(thanks Lex!), and has sent his Kryptonian army towards Earth. On New Krypton, Superman breaks free of Zod and his lackeys and flies towards the Kryptonian army, but is intercepted by Zod, Ursa and Non. Meanwhile, the ruler of New Krypton(and Supergirl's mother), Alura, is torturing the man responsible for the death of her husband, Reactron. Supergirl walks in on the torture session and yells at her mother for her actions. While the two women are arguing, Reaction chimes in and says that when Lex Luthor visited him during the Last Stand of New Krypton x-over, he left him with a parting gift from the Earth, and Reactron begins to glow very brightly. Alura shoves Supergirl into a nearby radiation deck(every torture chamber should have one...), and Reactron explodes with enough force to shatter the core of New Krypton and completely destroy the planet and everything on it. Superman and Zod and his forces stop their fight as they watch in horror as large chunks of New Krypton go sailing past them. On Earth, Jimmy Olsen and Lois Lane gather Guardian, Steel, Superboy, Krypto, Flamebird and Nightwing, and tell the heroes that Lois's crazy father was preparing to launch an attack on New Krypton. Lois's evil sister, Superwoman, watches the meeting from a distance. Superman flies through the remains of New Krypton and discovers Supergirl still alive, although she is the only living being he comes across. Supergirl is obviously shaken by the events that had happened, until she thinks back to Reactron's parting words and realizes that New Krypton was destroyed by agents of the Earth. SG pushes Supes away from her and begins to make a bee-line towards the Earth in a grief-filled rage. This issue ends with Zod appearing before his Kryptonian troops and telling them that their planet was destroyed by earthlings, and that they had no choice but to annihilate every single being on Earth in retribution.
What I Thought: Now THIS is the way to open up a mini-series! We got all of the major Superman players in motion, the war between Earth and the remnants of New Krypton is about to commence, and the story itself was petty powerful. The scene with Superman and Supergirl in space as they realize what had happened to their people was a thing of beauty. Even though there is no dialogue(they are in space and all), Jamal's pencils do a fantastic job of capturing the gravity of what had happened. Plus the little touches like Supergirl's tears freezing as they fell from her face was pretty sweet. So yeah, as an opening chapter of a mini-series, this comic was nearly perfect.
Score: 9 out of 10.Goodbye New Krypton...
James Robinson continues to absolutely confound me...one minute he's absolutely horrible on something like Cry for Justice, and the next he's knocking it out of the park with this miniseries. There can be only one explanation: there are two people named James Robinson writing comics for DC!!
ReplyDeleteOkay, maybe not...but it certainly seems like it sometimes. Maybe it's helped in this case by the fact that he has a co-writer? What do you think, X?
Lol Marc you've been saying some HILARIOUS stuff lately... Man if I didn't know better I'd think you want my King of Comedy Crown. But damn X you're making me wanna go pick these up with all these good ratings.
ReplyDeleteI personally love the idea that there's another guy named James Robinson out there! That had me chuckling...
ReplyDeleteJames Robinson: "It wasn't me who wrote that, it was that other, terrible James Robinson!!!"
I honestly don't know what to make of Cry for Justice Marc... I kind of want to say that Cry was a trainwreck because of editorial, and not James. Sure, he was the writer, but who knows how much of that story was his idea and how much of it came down from the DC offices. Then again, maybe James is the type of guy who needs a co-writer to bounce ideas off of...
Personally I'm more of the mindset that Cry was just a terrible aberration, and that normally James is a good to great writer.
I'd def recommend this entire mini JT. Even though you're not a huge Superman fan, I think this story is so good you don't have to be a huge Supes fan to enjoy it.
I am a huge Supes fan X, before It started I recall asking SOMEONE to catch me up to speed on it so I could read it, as payback for catching THEM up on Batgirl/Red Robin but it seems they forgot :P so I never picked it up.
ReplyDeleteOops...... :P I swear, I didn't think you were much of a Supes fan JT, I can't recall you ever really talking about Supes. Although I DO remember you asking for SOMEBODY *looks around* to fill you in with all things Supes before this mini got underway... But you know me, the laziness... I should have just pointed you towards my Supes: World of New Krypton and Last Stand reviews, but I guess the bottom line here is that I goofed!
ReplyDeleteAs much Smallville as I watch you don't think I'm a Supes fan? And as much Superman/Batman... Lol. And good point, but I'd rather blame you and your laziness :P
ReplyDeleteYeah, but Smallville isn't REALLY Superman is it? I mean, they don't even call Clark Supes in it do they? And yes, I'm obviously trying to distract you from my screw-up! Eh, blame me and my laziness. What do I care?! :P
ReplyDeleteNot YET lol but it's him, he's Clark Kent, and he's dating Lois, working at the daily planet, fought Doomsday, Zod and such :P And he got the suit in the last episode :P And I refuse to be led astray by your distraction tactics!!!
ReplyDeleteDamn it! I thought my master distraction abilities would work...... Hey JT, look behind you!!!!!
ReplyDeleteHeh-heh-heh...
Whats behind me?! *Turns around then back around* Where the hell is he?! I'll find you X, I SWEAR!!!! *Turns left* Oh.... there ya are... ya jerk. Lol
ReplyDeleteNicely done X... Nicely done. :P
ReplyDeleteLol You win this round... I have no reply. Move along, nothing to see here!
ReplyDelete